We (played as 2 players) found the game PDF really beautiful and the descriptions for specific clues well written, but our experience with the game was sort of lacking. Apart from drawing from the tower and the final guess there is nothing 'game-y' to do - you just randomly select paragraphs to read and then who is the killer and whether you find the killer is also entirely random. There are no decisions for the players to take. One simple thing that could improve this issue could be allowing the player to choose whoever they want to investigate (which suit to draw from) - so that there's at least a small aspect of 'strategy' in whether you want to focus on someone thoroughly to exclude them or spread out in your efforts.
Overall - cool idea and great packaging but left us hungry for more substance.